Categorized | News Article

The Waiting Game Ends Now – Time for the DREAM Act!

So, we all wait, and wait, and wait even longer for the Dream Act to have its chance.

A little over a year ago, the Dream Act was introduced as a stand-alone bill, and it was championed by mostly youth groups and passage was pushed.  In June, under the umbrella of Reform Enforcement Immigration for America, a conglomerate of organizations (largely DC based) began laying the groundwork for a long, disastrous campaign to push their version of “immigration reform” onto the masses.

From 2007, even before the CIR bill was introduced campaign officially kicked off, Dream youth were told to hold off on the DREAM Act.  We were told, point blank, that if we advocated for the DREAM Act we would be killing a larger reform package.  That by merely sharing our stories, we would be activating the anti-immigrant sentiment in the country and doing harm to everyone, including our parents.  We were shamed, called selfish, and ridiculed at every turn.  But through it all we managed to pull through with an an amazing movement to boot.  Where we were denied a seat at a table, we created our own table and, as youth, we reclaimed our own movement.  We are no longer dependent on privileged, usually white, out-of-touch organizers to do our bidding or for that matter even speak for us.  What does it tell you about your movement when the speakers don’t even represent the issue at hand?!  We can speak for ourselves.

Two years later with little to no funding and a completely undocumented and volunteer-run network we have accomplished so much, including:

  • A bill
  • 39 co-sponsors in the senate and 120 in the house
  • Dozens of deferred action for individual dream act students
  • An online presence which trumps that of any pro or anti immigrant group
  • 60,000 people on facebook and 40,000 on our general list, a list comprised mostly of young people ready to work for the DREAM
  • A strong network covering almost 30 states and presence in the rest

And the list continues.

All of this done with minimal money when compared to the $100,000,000 plus millions the Reform Enforcement Immigration for America campaign has received and spent.  And yet, we as the Dreamers are still told to wait, that it isn’t our time yet.  That we need to continue to push for a larger enforcement package, that if we were to push the DREAM Act, or piecemeal legislation, then we kill all the hope for a larger package.  Not to burst any bubbles but pieces of legislation have been passing for a while now.  SB1070 is just the latest piece in that collective.  While we sit around and fight each other, the Republicans are using an effective piecemeal approach: get anything you can and push for the large package only if it’s convenient.

We are at a fork in the road right now. If we continue to go the way we are going we will get neither the DREAM Act or any form of reform.  Our communities will suffer another defeat at the hands of people who are in it just for a pay-check, who are waiting to get invited to the next meeting in D.C., and have little regard for what is happening to our families and our youth.  A (not-so) wise man from within the Reform Immigration for America campaign recently caught me by surprise when he told me, during a semi-private phone call where I was berated for still pushing DREAM,  flat-out, “who says our communities need a win this year?”

Yes, you read it right.  The mantra that these people are working off of is “who says our communities need a win this year?!”

The immigrant youth want a win this year and are willing to do everything that needs to happen to get the win.  We are willing to put ourselves on the front lines as we have all the years past.  We are willing to walk 1500 miles.  We are willing to go on an indefinite hunger strike.  We are willing to conduct sit-ins at congressional and campaign offices and put ourselves into deportation proceedings.  We are willing to risk deportation.

So that brings me back to the fork in the road. We have two options right now: either we continue to play this waiting and pandering game to these groups that want nothing to do with us and care nothing about our futures, or we take a risk, we take a stand, and we push for the DREAM Act to pass as a stand alone bill.

Over the last month we have had a number of escalating actions.  These have taken place in the offices of non-supporting senators (Senator McCain -R AZ), supporting senators (Senator Feinstein -D CA) and our so-called allies (Gutierrez -D IL).  Soon we’ll add a few DC based ‘advocacy’ organizations to the list.  If the message is not clear yet, lets try and clear it up.  We, as youth, are not afraid of a challenge.  Everyone should be on notice: if you are not making the DREAM Act happen as a stand-alone bill, then you are a roadblock to DREAM, and we are going to call you out in a very public way.  If you won’t willingly take a stand to fight for our lives, then we’ll bring the moral crisis to your doorstep.

Our parents have waited too long and we have waited too long.  The time for the DREAM Act is now.

We are willing.  We are ready. We won’t wait.  You haven’t heard our thunder yet!

Next post:  List of organizations and names of individuals holding the DREAM Act hostage.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]
  • Pingback: Why Does it Feel Like too little too late with Elected Officials and Immigration? | VivirLatino

  • TexanMary

    Name the RI4A person who made that idiotic comment!

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/LaMarichola LaMarichola

    Viva los Dreamers! Its time for the Truth to come out!!

  • Jonathan Rodrigues

    As an ally I can't tell you what the youth movement should or shouldn't do, afterall I can only imagine the anger and frustration while futures are being held hostage by idiots in Washington. My parents were undocumented and most of my community still is. I know how it is to feel trapped.

    However, it's deeply dissapointing to see this divide, this incendiary rhetoric against the CIR movement. It gets nothing done. It does show your selfishness, and it creates an even greater generational and interest divide between the youth and the parents and older immigrants who have no chance at an eduation and will be screwed royally by a DREAM act with e-verify. So I challenge you, if you are going to push JUST for the DREAM act and leave the millions of other undocumented immigrants to dry, then you MUST fight TOOTH AND NAIL, harder than every before, to take out e-verify from this bill. Then and only then, will your piecemeal approach have a chance at working. Meanwhile, republicans and lazy, two-faced democrats will be gloating at how they dodged doing immigration reform for another five years by giving this student concession while hundreds of thousands will continue being deported.

    • http://prernalal.com Prerna Lal

      Actually no, you don't know how it feels to be an immigrant youth who has been treated the way DreamActivists were so you should just stop there. You can continue your disappointment though.

      Another person calling us selfish. Find something new to say. Or actually, rather do.

      • Jonathan Rodrigues

        It is selfish, by definition. But that is ok, I really do understand your position and as I've told my friend actively involved for DREAM in Maine, I don't blame you. I just don't like the super inflammatory rhetoric used by Mohammad in this post.

        The problem with this post, and the other replies is that it many times has the mentality that anyone that tries to criticize is against you, that everyone in the world is against you. That attitude is not helpful, and certainly not true.

        Here at Uchicago we are pushing our president to support Dream Act only, and I will go to dream act only events. I will be extremely happy if it passes. But the reality of what I said still stands. It will be years, no matter how much you push, before immigration returns, and if e-verify stays in the DREAM act bill it will be a tragedy for all.

        So all I'm calling for is a little less rhetoric and a little more moderation, that's all.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/juansaaa juansaaa

      #commentfail

      Lets talk about selfishness.

      Tell me Jonathan, am I selfish when my own parent tell that their hopes its that at least, yes AT LEAST, the Dream Act passes? They recognize that CIR is dead, they dont want us ALL to fail like it has been insinuated in previous posts.

      Youre right, will we have to fight next time around? Yes. But if we have done this wholeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee movement with volunteers, undocumented youth, 0$ monies, what makes you think that we are not gonna fight harder the next time around.

      We are in this fight for life. Selfish? I think NOT.

    • http://intensedebate.com/profiles/midreamact midreamact

      Hey Jonathan, I am selfish as a dreamer and proud of it. My selfishness though drives me to work for something tangible rather than just a paycheck.

      Keep your blinders on if you wish, your family will remain without status all the longer.

    • Azadeh

      Jonathan, what you said makes little logical sense. Nothing that you wrote explains how you came to the conclusion that passing the DREAM Act equals being selfish and not carrying about CIR. Nothing. Please take the time to break it down for me.

      the fact is that the DREAM Act, like many other civil rights legislation, can be brought to a vote as piecemeal legislation and passed RIGHT NOW, but the same cannot be said about CIR. Why should DREAM be held back because of that? and what makes you think that once DREAM is passed, these youth and their allies wont continue to fight for various other forms of immigration reform? if anything they will have a victory under their belt and better organizing tools to forge ahead. Why would you think that these youth are going to leave their families behind? this makes no sense.

      Are you arguing that NO legislation should ever move forward as a piecemeal legislation unless it's part of an overall reform package? or are you specifically against it when it comes to THIS issue, the DREAM Act, and CIR? Honestly, I have never heard such illogical arguments. Beneficial piecemeal legislation is regularly passed… again, look up basic US historical legislative bills having to do with environmental, health care, education, civil rights/liberties, etc. etc. issues — ugh ugh ugh. If you can't look it up for yourself, let me know! cuz I have no problem providing you w/ the links.

      It's graduation season and nearly 70,000 students will once again be left without opportunities to move on w/ their life. Potential doctors who may find a cure to various diseases, future engineers who may contribute to helping us clean up oil spills ;) teachers who will set the best example for future generations, or just artists and writers who will leave their own mark on the world… but now, their DREAMS are once again deferred, just like it was last year and the year before and the year before that. How is that right? Why should that continue if the bill has the ability of passing RIGHT NOW?!?

      If you were hungry and dying for some food, and someone offered you an appetizer sized meal, would you refuse to eat just because it was not a full sized entree? would you send the food away & tell them to only come back when they have an entire entree ready for you to eat? maybe that's a poor analogy, but honestly the logic that you're presenting does not make any sense to me.

      Try again.

    • gretch28

      Please tell me where you see e-verify mentioned in the DREAM Act? Ive read through the bill over and over since it was introduced in congress and i have never seen "that" part of the text. You know what frightens me is that you probably believe what your saying is the truth. False beliefs are what drive you and the false belief that our community is weak.

    • gretch28

      Here's my truth. We can have the DREAM Act and CIR. I have never considered myself choosing someone or a part of my community over the other. I am not selfish and my integrity speaks for itself. I have a voice. I have power and students have spent a majority of their time trying to get CIR passed this year. It would be nice to see people like you share your resources to support students in promoting the DREAM act. But you and i both know that you would not put aside your agenda or perhaps the agenda that others have told you you must have in order to win.

  • http://www.azdreamactcoaliton.org dreamgladiator

    Free the DREAM. We need our community leaders behind us. For too long we have been told to wait. The time is now to act and represent our youth. Time is imperitive, if we want immigration reform the DREAM Act is our best option. It is our only option.

  • adan

    right on, mano!

  • IMPATIENT DREAMER

    WE NEED THIS PASSED ASAP! NO MORE BULLSHIT, THEY ARE HOLDING US BACK. WASTING OUR TIME. WE HAVE LIVES WE NEED TO LIVE TOO. WE HAVE EARNED OUR DEGREES WORKING HARDER THAN THE AVERAGE STUDENT, BECAUSE WE DON'T QUALIFY FOR FINANCIAL AID. ENOUGH, IS ENOUGH! GET THIS PASSED!

    LETS GO!

  • Zelene

    Excellent article. For whatever its worth, I admit to being part of that road block, of taking a check (it should be noted that its a very small check) to contribute to a sham. Even though I still organize outside of NGO, and actively promote the practical law of SB 1528 and advocate for DREAM, I have no voice of substantial weigh in an organization that I have belonged to for more that 5 years. I may get reprimanded for writing this, but I no longer care, it must be said, many organizations and individuals, particularly on the Border, are disenchanted by the lack of litigation from the national campaign, by the ease in which the Border was traded in for a useless counter productive framework of a bill (Schummer-Lindsay). The ridiculous funds that went into the campaign made the movement inorganic and in many ways artificial. resources that could have truly changed the game, were wasted. The national campaign knows that if they lose DREAM as PART of CIR, they lose major litigation power, however they do nothing to nurture the brave, organic, truly grassroots and eloquent initiatives of the DREAMERS. Granted that its no secret I've had some words and bouts with my fellow DREAMERS, I am humbled by their persistence, initiative and courage and collective POWER of not being slaves to foundations. For some weeks now, I have made the decision to no longer contribute to the destruction of the movement. Unfortunately, that doesn't count for much, but now is a time where you must declare where you stand, beyond politics.

  • aaron

    Can I get a refund of my tax dollars?

  • jon

    Well done . Go for it. Start your own party and in time 50% of the USA of your age will vote for you and tour friends . I WILL.

  • Luisa

    From the first time I got involved in the DREAM movement, I knew CIR would hurt (as in delay) the passage of the DREAM Act. The criminals and gang members that politicians love to showcase as the reason for the dire need of stronger enforcement of immigration laws would never be given a chance to become citizens of this country through the DREAM Act.

    We need the DREAM Act now .. the US can't afford to lose anymore talent, intellect, and passion.

  • http://www.txdreamactalliance.com/ TX DREAM Act Alliance

    (cross posted from Facebook and updated)

    I have a similar set of concerns as Jonathan. It’s not that I am against pushing the DREAM Act as a standalone bill, but rather I am disturbed at the large amount of anti-immigration reform rhetoric coming from the DREAM Act movement.

    There is nothing wrong with critically assessing the strengths, weaknesses and failures of the national Comprehensive Immigration Reform Movement. However, when we spend more time attacking the CIR advocates and groups for everything they’ve try to do this year instead of: (a) focusing on a standalone DREAM Act bill; and (b) attacking anti-immigrant groups such as FAIR, NumbersUSA and similar groups, we are using our time and resources inefficiently.

    Mo, I believe we can push for a standalone bill this year without such angry rhetoric toward the CIR movement. I understand we are all frustrated with the failures of the RIFA campaign this year, but that is no reason to portray the CIRA movement as an enemy — which is what a lot of rhetoric seems to be doing. Do we really accomplish anything by attacking RIFA? I don’t think so.

    I think this sort of rhetoric turns off pro-CIR DREAM Advocates and poisons the well for future cooperation between CIR advocates and DREAMers.

    It is one thing to build the DREAM Act up, it is another to do so by tearing down CIR in the process.

    We can push a standalone DREAM Act bill without turning CIR into our enemy.

    Jose
    Texas DREAM Act Alliance

    • Jonathan Rodrigues

      exactly. There is no need to burn bridges and divide a movement that needs to be united, not divided.

      • http://intensedebate.com/profiles/midreamact midreamact

        We are united. It would be nice if the other groups would also unite behind a bill that has a chance of passing rather than stand in the way as a road block.

        Jose, don't worry we aren't spending time on the CIR groups, rather we have to get through them to get to the DREAM Act.

        If they weren't a roadblock we wouldn't even be mentioning them. We have more important things to do, but again. Without them moving out of the way there is no DREAM Act so don't think this is all because we are a bunch of petty little kids.

        We need to take those blinders off.

    • Pamela

      I agree, division will lead us no where. I am a dreamer who came here when I was 8 months old and am currently 21 years old, I know how it feels to live in fear that I could potentially be thrown into a country I know nothing about. I know the frustration that goes along waiting year after year after year.
      I would very much like the Dream Act to pass if nothing else, however, I don't think dividing groups helps the cause in any way shape or form.

  • Nan Ellzey

    One of my best friends, a wonderful degreed artist, whose parents brought her to this country as a child, faces a 16 year wait if she is caught and deported to Mexico, a country she doesn't even remember. I cannot imagine the fear she and her family have to deal with daily. I will do anything I can to support immigration change.

    • sue thatcher

      Nan, this is Sue Thatcher in San Antonio; are you the Nan Ellzey from San Antonio? my email is suzyden42@satx.rr.com; if this is you, please email me; I have been trying to find you.

      Sue

Join Our Mailing List

Take Action

Map of Immigrant Youth Activism


View Dream Act Activism in a larger map To get on the map, drop us an email at admin at dreamactivist.org

Archives